Icy Dilemma: Should You Use Ice for an Injury or Pain?

You’ve likely heard about the RICE method to help injuries or soreness — Rest, Ice, Compression, and Elevation. When you experience back pain or a sore knee, you may apply ice to help you recover and speed up healing. However, ice may not be the best solution for your unique situation. So, should you use ice or not? In short, the answer is… it depends.

To determine if icing is right for you and your injury, consider the following question: What are the goals of any actions taken after injury?

The big goal is to maximize blood flow to assist healing. Vasodilation, or expansion of blood vessels, increases blood flow and delivers oxygen, nutrition, hydration, and tissue repair product to the site of injury. Inflammation is part of that process. All of your treatment choices should be based on this.

  1. Ice for acute injuries, such as an ankle sprain.
    Yes, but only apply ice 10 minutes at a time. Ice will numb the pain if severe, but applying ice for long durations can cause rebound swelling. Elevation and compression are key components to control swelling after immediate injury. There will likely be significant early joint swelling. This is the body’s mechanism of placing a cast around an injury, which is normal. However, uncontrolled, massive swelling will hinder those blood vessels from expanding, in turn, reducing fluid exchange and slowing the healing process.
  2. Ice for Delayed Onset of Muscle Soreness after exercise.
    No, ice application will not help with Delayed Onset of Muscle Soreness (DOMS) after exercise. DOMS is the accumulation of metabolic waste product in muscles and tendons after moderate to heavy use. Think “I need to flush this system clean” to clear the waste sitting there. In this situation, elevation is the best choice to let gravity do the work for you. You will see endurance athletes, runners, soccer players, cyclists, etc. lie on the floor with feet up on a wall to assist with flushing the system clean; just 15 minutes will do the trick. This is my go-to when my legs feel dead and sludgy after a long run or cycling session. Next, get moving with a slow and easy warm up the next day. Walking, easy cycling, or swimming will increase the heart rate and improve blood flow to assist with flushing the system clean.
  3. Ice for muscle spasms.
    Yes, ice will work as an anti-spasmodic. Application of ice for 10 minutes will calm a muscle spasm and allow you to start moving. Numbness is not pain and the movement it allows will help the healing. Controlled pain allows movement, which expands blood vessels to increase oxygen, hydration, and nutrition to promote healing. For example, ice application on the neck at the base of the skull will stop a suboccipital headache almost every time.
  4. Ice for pain relief.
    If you have a long history of overuse injuries due to training or competition and tournament or international rules prohibit the use of pharmaceuticals, then ice application to control pain and swelling to get you through the competition is acceptable. Do not forget about elevation and compression. After the tournament or competition, maximize blood flow to assist with healing. For example, if you are experiencing horrific pain and cannot move to increase blood flow, heat application is like throwing gasoline on a fire and the pain will likely get worse. In this case, ice application for several bouts of 10 minutes will move your pain meter in the correct direction. Then, beginning to move will lead to vasodilation and promote healing.

You may also enjoy: Heat vs. Ice – Which is Better for Your Pain?

Share This Post:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
RehaBlog

More Posts

5 Exercises For Concussions

A concussion is defined as a mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) induced by direct or indirect force transmitted to the head. Looking at the statistics, there were 27.16 million new TBI cases globally in 2019. Nationally, there were approximately 214,110 TBI-related hospitalizations in 2020 and 69,473 TBI-related deaths in 2021.² Approximately 80% of all TBIs are classified as mild head injuries (CDC). These numbers highlight the significant public health impact concussions have worldwide, and the importance of proper evaluation and management.

What to Wear to Physical Therapy

When heading to physical therapy, comfort and functionality are key. Your attire can significantly impact the effectiveness of your session, affecting your ability to move freely, follow your therapist’s instructions, and perform exercises with ease. The right clothing not only promotes flexibility but also allows your therapist to evaluate your movements and address areas that need attention. Here’s what to wear – and what to avoid – for a successful visit!

Signs of a Traumatic Brain Injury You May Not Know

What exactly is a traumatic brain injury? A traumatic brain injury (TBI) is an injury to the brain that can be caused by a forceful jolt, bump, or hit to the head. It can also be caused by a sharp object that pushes through the skull and into the brain. Such injuries are often caused by car accidents, falls, sports, or natural disasters. For example, a concussion is a mild form of TBI; however, not all injuries to the head will cause a TBI.

Floor Transfers: Why They’re Important

Floor transfers, the ability to get down and rise from the floor without assistance, are an indicator of an individual’s functional independence, quality of life, and a predictor of longevity and overall health. This seemingly simple movement represents a complex integration of strength, flexibility, balance, and coordination that is closely linked to one’s overall functional mobility.

Heart Healthy Foods

Five Foods That Promote Heart Health

Heart disease remains the leading cause of death among men, women, and most ethnic groups in the United States. While some risk factors—such as age, gender, and family history—are beyond our control, many other factors can be managed through lifestyle choices. Diet, physical activity, stress management, and avoiding tobacco all play a critical role in supporting heart health.

Start your Journey

Learn more about Sheltering Arms Institute

Contact a specialist at Sheltering Arms Institute to learn more about how you can gain more freedom in your everyday life.